New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] Edna or Millay?
What do you think of Edna and Millay? Both would be as middle names. I absolutely adore Edna St. Vincent Millay, you see.
Are there any nice combos you can think of with them? I was thinking about Cornelia Millay, but I'm having trouble with Edna.
Array (working on memorizing a Millay poem for class)
She had fallen against the windows, which were pressed against the windows, which were pressed against the old oak near across the age of the old Aunt Sophronia--was almost dreadful enough to walk on.
A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.
Are there any nice combos you can think of with them? I was thinking about Cornelia Millay, but I'm having trouble with Edna.
Array (working on memorizing a Millay poem for class)
She had fallen against the windows, which were pressed against the windows, which were pressed against the old oak near across the age of the old Aunt Sophronia--was almost dreadful enough to walk on.
A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
Edna - I like Edna but not enough to use it myself
Millay - I tend to dislike surnamey names but thisdoesnt sound too bad any idea of its meaning
Beatrice Edna ( My mother in laws name was Edna Beatrice but it works fine both ways I think )
Bridget Edna
Charlotte Edna
Gillian Edna
Harriet Edna
Josephine Edna ( though I prefer Edna Josephine )
Lucy Edna
Margaret Edna
Susan Edna
Millay - I tend to dislike surnamey names but thisdoesnt sound too bad any idea of its meaning
Beatrice Edna ( My mother in laws name was Edna Beatrice but it works fine both ways I think )
Bridget Edna
Charlotte Edna
Gillian Edna
Harriet Edna
Josephine Edna ( though I prefer Edna Josephine )
Lucy Edna
Margaret Edna
Susan Edna
1
Edna is OK, but too old-fashioned sounding to me. Millay is OK too, strange though.
I personally hate Cornelia, the combo with Millay is not too nice. They don't really go good with each other.
Edna is difficult as a MN, looks and sounds better as a FN. You could take it as the FN but call the child by the MN.
What about:
Edna Felice
Edna Jillian
Edna Felicity
Edna Ruthie
Edna Pauline
Edna Zoe
Edna Samantha
Edna Katie
Edna Urszula
Edna Riley
Edna Alexandra/Alexzandra
Edna Julie
Edna Jamie
Edna Hillary/Hilary
Edna Lindsey/Lindsay
Edna Maureen
Edna Mabel
Hope this helps!
My current favorite names that I would give my children:
~ Liv Samantha ~
* Mia *
° Lia °
" Kim "
+ Keira +
I personally hate Cornelia, the combo with Millay is not too nice. They don't really go good with each other.
Edna is difficult as a MN, looks and sounds better as a FN. You could take it as the FN but call the child by the MN.
What about:
Edna Felice
Edna Jillian
Edna Felicity
Edna Ruthie
Edna Pauline
Edna Zoe
Edna Samantha
Edna Katie
Edna Urszula
Edna Riley
Edna Alexandra/Alexzandra
Edna Julie
Edna Jamie
Edna Hillary/Hilary
Edna Lindsey/Lindsay
Edna Maureen
Edna Mabel
Hope this helps!
My current favorite names that I would give my children:
~ Liv Samantha ~
* Mia *
° Lia °
" Kim "
+ Keira +
1
Oh, I wouldn't go all-out and name a child completely after her, I don't think. Plus, I don't like Millicent at all--I find it too sickly-sweet, and too easily revived. Plus, I simply love the sound of Millay; it's very pretty.
Edna might not be particularly popular among other people, but neither is Doris, and I still love it. :D
Array (thanks you kindly for your help)
She had fallen against the windows, which were pressed against the windows, which were pressed against the old oak near across the age of the old Aunt Sophronia--was almost dreadful enough to walk on.
A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.
Edna might not be particularly popular among other people, but neither is Doris, and I still love it. :D
Array (thanks you kindly for your help)
She had fallen against the windows, which were pressed against the windows, which were pressed against the old oak near across the age of the old Aunt Sophronia--was almost dreadful enough to walk on.
A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.
1
OK, gotcha.
Sorry, I went back and re-read your original post. I didn't get that Edna / Millay would be mns only. How about:
Rosamund Edna
Winifred Edna (Too much "ed" perhaps, but stylistically they match, to me.)
Beatrice / Beatrix Edna
Guinevere Edna
Ingrid Edna
Wilhelmina Edna (Mina)
Muriel Edna (This one has the best flow, to me)
Vivien Edna
Ottoline / Ottilie Edna
Bernadette Edna
Constance Edna
Miriam Edna (Miri, Mimi, Mim)
Lenore Edna
Nell Edna
Saskia Millay
Astrid Millay
Iris Millay
Sylvia Millay (my favorite of these, although Cornelia Millay is terrific too)
Jacintha Millay
Ailsa Millay
Henrietta Millay (Harriet / Hattie / Hettie / Etta / Ettie)
Georgina Millay
Eugenia Millay (Genia, Genie)
Sorry, I went back and re-read your original post. I didn't get that Edna / Millay would be mns only. How about:
Rosamund Edna
Winifred Edna (Too much "ed" perhaps, but stylistically they match, to me.)
Beatrice / Beatrix Edna
Guinevere Edna
Ingrid Edna
Wilhelmina Edna (Mina)
Muriel Edna (This one has the best flow, to me)
Vivien Edna
Ottoline / Ottilie Edna
Bernadette Edna
Constance Edna
Miriam Edna (Miri, Mimi, Mim)
Lenore Edna
Nell Edna
Saskia Millay
Astrid Millay
Iris Millay
Sylvia Millay (my favorite of these, although Cornelia Millay is terrific too)
Jacintha Millay
Ailsa Millay
Henrietta Millay (Harriet / Hattie / Hettie / Etta / Ettie)
Georgina Millay
Eugenia Millay (Genia, Genie)
1
Hee, hee, partner who needs convincing. I won't have one of those for QUITE a while--but it's kind of you to think ahead! ;D
I think that someday, I might warm up to Edna as a first name--but it might take a while. I like its sound--but then, I've discovered that I really like D's in names. :)
Of your suggestions, I like:
Rosamunde Edna
Winifred Edna
Guinnevere Edna
Wilhelmina Edna (but I would call her Billie, I think :)
Muriel Edna (I do love Muriel)
Bernadette Edna (perhaps a Bettie, Etta, or Detta)
Miriam Edna (or perhaps Mariam Edna? I love Mariam, too)
Lenore Edna (I'm a bit more a fan of Elenore, but Lenore is lovely)
Iris Millay
Sylvia Millay (It's wonderfully poetic--I love Sylvia Plath as well as Millay :)
Unfortunately, a lot of them are too fancy for me to ever seriously consider! They'd all be very nice on someone else's child, but I think I'd need to pick something a little more down-home, lol. Less upper-crust, British sounding, you know?
Others that have popped into my head, none of which are particularly serious considerations right now:
June Millay
Solveig Edna
Gilda Millay (though I still like Gilda Rae best)
I think that someday, I might warm up to Edna as a first name--but it might take a while. I like its sound--but then, I've discovered that I really like D's in names. :)
Of your suggestions, I like:
Rosamunde Edna
Winifred Edna
Guinnevere Edna
Wilhelmina Edna (but I would call her Billie, I think :)
Muriel Edna (I do love Muriel)
Bernadette Edna (perhaps a Bettie, Etta, or Detta)
Miriam Edna (or perhaps Mariam Edna? I love Mariam, too)
Lenore Edna (I'm a bit more a fan of Elenore, but Lenore is lovely)
Iris Millay
Sylvia Millay (It's wonderfully poetic--I love Sylvia Plath as well as Millay :)
Unfortunately, a lot of them are too fancy for me to ever seriously consider! They'd all be very nice on someone else's child, but I think I'd need to pick something a little more down-home, lol. Less upper-crust, British sounding, you know?
Others that have popped into my head, none of which are particularly serious considerations right now:
June Millay
Solveig Edna
Gilda Millay (though I still like Gilda Rae best)
1
Fun.
Wilhelmina, nn Billie is darling. And I love Mariam too.
I'm so happy you like Sylvia! Iris Murdoch, while not a poet, fits into the literary theme nicely. I was in a store yesterday and a mother called out to her four or five year old Iris. I smiled all the way through that store.
June Millay -- Sweet. I've always thought Juno was beautiful. Probably not down to earth enough for you, though. I know what you mean about making the name easy for the child to live with.
Solveig Edna -- Gorgeous. But she'll have pronunciation problems, at least here in the U.S.
Gilda Millay -- Love it. I just saw Rita Hayworth in Gild for the first time the other day.
Ingeborg Edna -- Oh. Ottoline is not down to earth enough for you, but Ingeborg is? The deck is stacked against me.*
Juniper Edna -- You must, you must, you must. Love it.
Janis Edna / Millay -- A Joplin fan? Personally, I prefer the Janice spelling. But it's not a favorite name of mine either way.
Janine Millay -- There must be a hundred ways to spell this name. I love Jeanine, nn Jeanie. Any chance? I suppose Nina would also work as a nn.
* Tongue planted firmly in cheek.
Wilhelmina, nn Billie is darling. And I love Mariam too.
I'm so happy you like Sylvia! Iris Murdoch, while not a poet, fits into the literary theme nicely. I was in a store yesterday and a mother called out to her four or five year old Iris. I smiled all the way through that store.
June Millay -- Sweet. I've always thought Juno was beautiful. Probably not down to earth enough for you, though. I know what you mean about making the name easy for the child to live with.
Solveig Edna -- Gorgeous. But she'll have pronunciation problems, at least here in the U.S.
Gilda Millay -- Love it. I just saw Rita Hayworth in Gild for the first time the other day.
Ingeborg Edna -- Oh. Ottoline is not down to earth enough for you, but Ingeborg is? The deck is stacked against me.*
Juniper Edna -- You must, you must, you must. Love it.
Janis Edna / Millay -- A Joplin fan? Personally, I prefer the Janice spelling. But it's not a favorite name of mine either way.
Janine Millay -- There must be a hundred ways to spell this name. I love Jeanine, nn Jeanie. Any chance? I suppose Nina would also work as a nn.
* Tongue planted firmly in cheek.
1
I am a fan of Iris Murdoch as well, though I don't know her works nearly as well as I do Edna and Sylvia's. :) I always patted her books lovingly when I passed them at work, as well as Muriel Spark's!
I suspect I might end up living out my life in my hometown, where I have known kids named Ingrid (x3), Lars, Nils, Bjorn, Sigrid, etc. So Solveig wouldn't have too much trouble growing up, at least.
I think the difference between Ottoline and Ingeborg are the endings. The -line ending is too much like Angeline-Marcelline-etc, while -borg isn't quite so heavenwards. ;) Plus, Ingeborg was the name of my first Norwegian ancestor to come to America, and familial legend has it that she walked quite a bit of the way to the Midwest--thus, Ingeborg sounds quite tough to me. I do like Ottilie and Bertilia, though--so I'm not completely hopeless, honestly.
Juniper sounds absolutely fabulous with all two-syllable-with-emphasis-on-first-syllable names, it seems. Juniper Edna will be on the Juniper shortlist with Juniper Sara and Juniper Frances.
And yes, I'm a Joplin fan. :) And the reason I like Janine as it's spelled is because of the David Bowie song by the same name. A Janine of mine would likely be called Jannie or perhaps Janey. Jeanie is already what I call my sister Sara, you see. :D
Array (tongue planted firmly in mouth)
She had fallen against the windows, which were pressed against the windows, which were pressed against the old oak near across the age of the old Aunt Sophronia--was almost dreadful enough to walk on.
A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.
I suspect I might end up living out my life in my hometown, where I have known kids named Ingrid (x3), Lars, Nils, Bjorn, Sigrid, etc. So Solveig wouldn't have too much trouble growing up, at least.
I think the difference between Ottoline and Ingeborg are the endings. The -line ending is too much like Angeline-Marcelline-etc, while -borg isn't quite so heavenwards. ;) Plus, Ingeborg was the name of my first Norwegian ancestor to come to America, and familial legend has it that she walked quite a bit of the way to the Midwest--thus, Ingeborg sounds quite tough to me. I do like Ottilie and Bertilia, though--so I'm not completely hopeless, honestly.
Juniper sounds absolutely fabulous with all two-syllable-with-emphasis-on-first-syllable names, it seems. Juniper Edna will be on the Juniper shortlist with Juniper Sara and Juniper Frances.
And yes, I'm a Joplin fan. :) And the reason I like Janine as it's spelled is because of the David Bowie song by the same name. A Janine of mine would likely be called Jannie or perhaps Janey. Jeanie is already what I call my sister Sara, you see. :D
Array (tongue planted firmly in mouth)
She had fallen against the windows, which were pressed against the windows, which were pressed against the old oak near across the age of the old Aunt Sophronia--was almost dreadful enough to walk on.
A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.
1