View Message

1.amaya
2.paige
3.amaia
4.skye

I like both Maya and Maia, but the a feels tacked on. They're not bad names, but not my cup of tea.
Skye > Amaia > Amaya > Paige.

Amaya most, Skye least.

Amaya and I like it better than the others, May or Maeve are nice too

If we're talking Basque names, Maialen has always intrigued me. But of the names you offered, I prefer the Amaia spelling - and I do prefer it to Paige, and definitely like it more than Skye.

I don't like it too much. It doesn't have a nice meaning ('the end') and it feels like someone just put an A in front of Maya or Maia, made up, even though I know it isn't. It also feels so trendy. I have the feeling everyone on the internet likes it because of an unreliable Japanese meaning it got assigned to it (it has no history of usage in Japan) and it seems even more current and trendy because of that, something a teenager would choose to write fan fiction for an anime or something. No offense, I just dislike it.

---

To be honest all of them feel trendy or formerly trendy. Paige is 90s, Skye 2000s and Amaya feels very 2010s. I like Paige and Skye but not enough to use.

---

Where I live Paige and Skye don't work so I would have to use Amaia (this spelling is a little better, in my opinion, but I think most people would spell it Amaya).

I like Amaya the best.
Skye the least.