New Post
Search
Help[Games] Re: Compromise Game
in reply to a message by myth
Having thought about it more, I moved up Fiona. What do you think of naming one of each gender and then randomly determining the third?
some possible combos-
Lysander James, Lysander Rhys, Lysander Cedric, Lysander Hugo, Lysander Phillip
Adrian Lewis
Hugo Dominic
Rowan Andreas, Rowan Isaac
Ivy Cressida
Fiona Sybil
Eleanor Hazel "Nora"
FN:
Adrian
Callum
Cedric
Cormac
Hugo
Lysander
Raphael
Rowan
MN only:
Andreas
Dominic
Evander
Edmund*
Isaac
James
Lewis
Oliver
Orion
Phillip
Rhys
Silas
Sylvan
Thomas
Valentin
Vincent
FN:
Alice
Eleanor "Nora"
Gwen
Fiona
Freya
Ivy
MN only:
Cressida
Diana
Elodie
Hazel
Isobel
Miriam
Rosemary
Sybil
Viola
some possible combos-
Lysander James, Lysander Rhys, Lysander Cedric, Lysander Hugo, Lysander Phillip
Adrian Lewis
Hugo Dominic
Rowan Andreas, Rowan Isaac
Ivy Cressida
Fiona Sybil
Eleanor Hazel "Nora"
FN:
Adrian
Callum
Cedric
Cormac
Hugo
Lysander
Raphael
Rowan
MN only:
Andreas
Dominic
Evander
Edmund*
Isaac
James
Lewis
Oliver
Orion
Phillip
Rhys
Silas
Sylvan
Thomas
Valentin
Vincent
FN:
Alice
Eleanor "Nora"
Gwen
Fiona
Freya
Ivy
MN only:
Cressida
Diana
Elodie
Hazel
Isobel
Miriam
Rosemary
Sybil
Viola
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
Sounds like a good idea. I got a boy when I flipped the coin.
Combos:
Lysander James, Lysander Rhys, Lysander Phillip
Adrian Lewis
Hugo Dominic, Hugo Evander?
Callum Andreas?, Callum Evander?, Callum Orion?
Cedric Rhys?
Cormac Thomas?
Raphael Sylvan?, Raphael Andreas?
Rowan Andreas, Rowan Isaac
Ivy Cressida
Fiona Sybil
Eleanor Hazel "Nora", Eleanor Miriam "Nora"?
Alice Viola?
Gwen Isobel?
Freya Rosemary?
What do you think of the combos I suggested and what are your overall favorites, ranked?
Combos:
Lysander James, Lysander Rhys, Lysander Phillip
Adrian Lewis
Hugo Dominic, Hugo Evander?
Callum Andreas?, Callum Evander?, Callum Orion?
Cedric Rhys?
Cormac Thomas?
Raphael Sylvan?, Raphael Andreas?
Rowan Andreas, Rowan Isaac
Ivy Cressida
Fiona Sybil
Eleanor Hazel "Nora", Eleanor Miriam "Nora"?
Alice Viola?
Gwen Isobel?
Freya Rosemary?
What do you think of the combos I suggested and what are your overall favorites, ranked?
1
Let's see.
Basically I'm really excited about the fact that I found someone else that likes the name Lysander, so even though I like both of your Evander combos, using both seems too matchy. I like all 3 of those combos about the same and for different reasons, so I'm more interested in your input there. If I were to give a #1 to anything, it'd probably be getting to use a Lysander combo.
I like the name Rowan quite a bit but don't feel as good about the combos for it, and I like Callum Orion but both together are a bit GP-y.
Adrian Lewis, Cormac Thomas, Cedric Rhys, and Hugo Dominic are all nice. Raphael Sylvan is more out there but seems super cool to me.
I would like to also suggest Alice Freya.
My favorite girls combos are Ivy Cressida, Fiona Sybil, Gwen Isobel, and Freya Rosemary.
Idk if this is a strange way to go about this, but it's kinda easier for me to decide between them personally when I think of it as a whole sibset than ranking combos individually. I like Lysander Rhys and Raphael Sylvan together and have trouble seeing Raphael Sylvan fitting with the other boys combos, and I would put any of the girls' combos with those two except for Gwen Isobel.
I have trouble seeing Adrian and Lysander as brothers (though Adrian goes nicely with most of the others), and Cormac and Cedric are a bit matchy. If Lysander and Hugo are brothers, I'll feel biased toward using Ivy Cressida for the Shakespeare theme :b.
Would love your input.
Basically I'm really excited about the fact that I found someone else that likes the name Lysander, so even though I like both of your Evander combos, using both seems too matchy. I like all 3 of those combos about the same and for different reasons, so I'm more interested in your input there. If I were to give a #1 to anything, it'd probably be getting to use a Lysander combo.
I like the name Rowan quite a bit but don't feel as good about the combos for it, and I like Callum Orion but both together are a bit GP-y.
Adrian Lewis, Cormac Thomas, Cedric Rhys, and Hugo Dominic are all nice. Raphael Sylvan is more out there but seems super cool to me.
I would like to also suggest Alice Freya.
My favorite girls combos are Ivy Cressida, Fiona Sybil, Gwen Isobel, and Freya Rosemary.
Idk if this is a strange way to go about this, but it's kinda easier for me to decide between them personally when I think of it as a whole sibset than ranking combos individually. I like Lysander Rhys and Raphael Sylvan together and have trouble seeing Raphael Sylvan fitting with the other boys combos, and I would put any of the girls' combos with those two except for Gwen Isobel.
I have trouble seeing Adrian and Lysander as brothers (though Adrian goes nicely with most of the others), and Cormac and Cedric are a bit matchy. If Lysander and Hugo are brothers, I'll feel biased toward using Ivy Cressida for the Shakespeare theme :b.
Would love your input.
1
I agree that Lysander is a must here. We both seem to prefer it. I like Lysander Rhys the best, as it flows well and seems balanced.
In terms of other boy names I prefer Hugo and Raphael. For Hugo, Hugo Dominic seems to be the obvious choice. Though I like both Raphael combos, you seem to be leaning towards Raphael Sylvan and I'm happy to go with that. That leaves us with either Lysander Rhys and Hugo Dominic or Lysander Rhys and Raphael Sylvan.
For girls... I'm not as happy with the girls names as I am with the boys names, but they're still good. I think my favorites, going by first names alone, are Fiona, Ivy, and Freya, in that order. So Fiona Sybil, Ivy Cressida, or Freya Rosemary.
I don't know if this makes sense or not, but since both Lysander and Raphael are fairly long (three syllables), I would generally match them with another longer name. In this case, Fiona has the most syllables. Lysander and Hugo differ in length enough that I could pair them with any of the girl names. I think the Shakespearian feel of Lysander Rhys, Hugo Dominic, and Ivy Cressida is cool, so Ivy does seem the obvious choice if we decide on Lysander and Hugo.
I think we're down to two choices:
Lysander Rhys, Raphael Sylvan, and Fiona Sybil
OR
Lysander Rhys, Hugo Dominic, and Ivy Cressida
Are those good do you think? Or are there more choices you would like to add? Which do you prefer?
In terms of other boy names I prefer Hugo and Raphael. For Hugo, Hugo Dominic seems to be the obvious choice. Though I like both Raphael combos, you seem to be leaning towards Raphael Sylvan and I'm happy to go with that. That leaves us with either Lysander Rhys and Hugo Dominic or Lysander Rhys and Raphael Sylvan.
For girls... I'm not as happy with the girls names as I am with the boys names, but they're still good. I think my favorites, going by first names alone, are Fiona, Ivy, and Freya, in that order. So Fiona Sybil, Ivy Cressida, or Freya Rosemary.
I don't know if this makes sense or not, but since both Lysander and Raphael are fairly long (three syllables), I would generally match them with another longer name. In this case, Fiona has the most syllables. Lysander and Hugo differ in length enough that I could pair them with any of the girl names. I think the Shakespearian feel of Lysander Rhys, Hugo Dominic, and Ivy Cressida is cool, so Ivy does seem the obvious choice if we decide on Lysander and Hugo.
I think we're down to two choices:
Lysander Rhys, Raphael Sylvan, and Fiona Sybil
OR
Lysander Rhys, Hugo Dominic, and Ivy Cressida
Are those good do you think? Or are there more choices you would like to add? Which do you prefer?
1
Raphael Andreas felt too German to me in combination haha. I liked how it sounded but it didn't fit with the other names so well for me. I agree that our boys taste is much more similar and we got lucky with the coin flip.
I've been going back and forth on this because I like both quite a bit. I think between the two I would pick Lysander/Hugo/Ivy but if we found a perfect Fiona combo I'd likely lean the other way.
Fiona Alice is pretty cute. I heavily associate it with Fiona Apple (which is not really a bad thing).
Fiona Cressida (kind of a mouthful but)
Fiona Hazel
Fiona Gwen
Fiona Gwendolyn (I like this!! very UK but. Gwendolen is fine too, just wrote the other spelling because both the other MNs have y's)
Fiona Ivy (even though it's a lot of "ee" this is a favorite)
Fiona Isobel (I think this fits well with the boys combos, just wasn't sure if "Isobel" was too fillery. I guess Rhys kinda is anyway)
Fiona Miriam
I wish Fiona flowed better with Rosemary :b
Some of these MNs seem less interesting than the boys. I just don't like the Sylvan/Sybil combination. I guess we could revisit Raphael either but I was happier with Raphael Sylvan.
I've been going back and forth on this because I like both quite a bit. I think between the two I would pick Lysander/Hugo/Ivy but if we found a perfect Fiona combo I'd likely lean the other way.
Fiona Alice is pretty cute. I heavily associate it with Fiona Apple (which is not really a bad thing).
Fiona Cressida (kind of a mouthful but)
Fiona Hazel
Fiona Gwen
Fiona Gwendolyn (I like this!! very UK but. Gwendolen is fine too, just wrote the other spelling because both the other MNs have y's)
Fiona Ivy (even though it's a lot of "ee" this is a favorite)
Fiona Isobel (I think this fits well with the boys combos, just wasn't sure if "Isobel" was too fillery. I guess Rhys kinda is anyway)
Fiona Miriam
I wish Fiona flowed better with Rosemary :b
Some of these MNs seem less interesting than the boys. I just don't like the Sylvan/Sybil combination. I guess we could revisit Raphael either but I was happier with Raphael Sylvan.
This message was edited 7/6/2016, 12:05 PM
1
I agree that Sybil and Sylvan are quite similar and it makes sense to try and find a better combination for Fiona. I don't mind any of those combos. They flow pretty well and are unique in their own way. I think in order I like:
Fiona Gwendolyn (I'm not usually in to matching names, but connecting all the middles with a y seems neat.)
Fiona Alice (I've never heard of Fiona Apple...)
Fiona Hazel
Fiona Ivy (I'm going back and forth on this one. I really can't decide whether I like it or not.)
Fiona Isobel (I think my problem with both this and Fiona Ivy is the last a flowing into the beginning i. It's probably just me though.)
Fiona Miriam (A lot of ee sounds the way I pronounce it.)
Fiona Cressida
Fiona Gwen (I think something seems missing with Gwen not shortened.)
Fiona Gwendolyn (I'm not usually in to matching names, but connecting all the middles with a y seems neat.)
Fiona Alice (I've never heard of Fiona Apple...)
Fiona Hazel
Fiona Ivy (I'm going back and forth on this one. I really can't decide whether I like it or not.)
Fiona Isobel (I think my problem with both this and Fiona Ivy is the last a flowing into the beginning i. It's probably just me though.)
Fiona Miriam (A lot of ee sounds the way I pronounce it.)
Fiona Cressida
Fiona Gwen (I think something seems missing with Gwen not shortened.)
1
Fiona Apple's a singer-songwriter. It's just the Fiona A that makes me think of that.
I'm happy with Lysander Rhys, Raphael Sylvan, and Fiona Gwendolyn. It's been fun!
The Compromise Game actually migrated over to Name Games when it was brought up on Ops initially and I've ran two Congrats games kinda based on it. I'm now thinking of doing a third since it's been a few months. :)
I'm happy with Lysander Rhys, Raphael Sylvan, and Fiona Gwendolyn. It's been fun!
The Compromise Game actually migrated over to Name Games when it was brought up on Ops initially and I've ran two Congrats games kinda based on it. I'm now thinking of doing a third since it's been a few months. :)
1