View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

[Opinions] Congratulations
Congrats and thank you for letting us in on such a great name. I love how retro and musical Hilda is. It's funny. My sister is Hilary Patricia, but my mother's nn for her has always been Hildy Mary. I had to blink twice when I saw the name Hilda May in your title. :-) Plus, I'd name a dd Niamh, so this whole combo has me reeling.And how sweet for your MIL. Nice to hear.Sean is OK, not a personal favorite. It's nice to see Jamie used for a boy, although I would have prefered it as a nn for James. Aine Brid is gorgeous, as is Eibhlin. Tell me, when you say it's pronounced like Evelyn, do you mean, "EV-uh-lin" or "EEV-lin?" Because I used to think Eibhlin was pronounced "EEV-lin" and it was a top ten name for me. But then I found out how differently it is pronounced all over Ireland and I gave up on it, sadly. Just curious. Thanks for bringing a smile to my face this Monday morning. :-D

This message was edited 2/7/2011, 10:36 AM

Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Aw glad you like it. I found out after I posted that it's Hilda-Mae - I still think it's great though.I asked my husband and he reckons it's EV-uh-lin but I don't think he knows for sure. How frustrating for the name nerd!
vote up1
Hilda Mae is even sweeter. :-)Thanks for asking the hubbie about Eibhlin. If I recall correctly, your in Ireland (which means it's bed-time for you). How would you pronounce Eibhlin? I'm desperately trying to find a way out of "ayv-leen." If Eimear is "EE-mer," why can't Eibhlin be "EEV-lin" or even "eev-LEEN?" I know, I know. Because it's Irish. ETA: "you're in Ireland" not "your in Ireland" (blushes)

This message was edited 2/8/2011, 10:45 AM

vote up1
I said to him that his mission is to definitively find out what the child's name is! He saw it written down on FB when she was born and said her name was Eileen. I asked him if it couldn't be EV-i-lin instead and he said later that he thought it was. But he can't remember now if he found out for sure if it is Ev-i-lin, Eev-lin, Av-el-een or something else. The reason I thought it was Ev-i-lin was because there is a trend in Ireland for parents to use Irish spellings for English sounding names like Aoibhe for Eva. I have known two Eibhlíns IRL and they both were I-leen! They were both from Kerry. I think EEV-lin for Eibhlin or EEV-leen for Eibhlín is quite legitimate actually. However the EEv-lin prn is not used here much at all for Evelyn. So they would be more likely to use the EV-i-lin prn instead if that's the route they are going.
Irish names are weird. In one sense there is a right way and a wrong way of saying them. But there also is variation during to regions - and changes due to the influence of the fact that most of the population speak English as their first language. A good example of this is Aoibheann. The original proper Irish way is EE-vin. But people use it and say it Aveen and I reckon this prn is as popular as Ee-vin. Another good example is Siobhán - subtle and not so subtle regional differences due to what part of the country the speaker is from.Hope all this helped rather than confused.
vote up1
Thank you!Thanks. You put a lot of effort into helping me. I really appreciate that. :-DYour poor husband. I don't want to put him to any trouble. I'm satisfied now that my prefered pronunciation ('EEV-lin") is just as legitimate as any other. Thanks for putting that to rest for me. Yay, Eibhlin! I'm free to love you again! Yay, Speranza!
vote up1